Expert Overview: Orbital (Eye Socket) Fractures – Medicolegal Considerations
Prepared by: Prof. Simon Holmes FDS RCS FRCS
Consultant Oral & Maxillofacial Surgeon
Specialist in Orbital Trauma and Reconstruction
The orbit is a complex anatomical structure comprising thin bones that house and protect the eye, its muscles, nerves, and associated soft tissues. Damage to this structure — whether from assault, road traffic collision, workplace accident, or sporting injury — has the potential to cause permanent functional and aesthetic harm.
In my capacity as a Consultant Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon with over two decades’ experience at the Royal London Hospital, one of Europe’s largest major trauma centres, I have managed thousands of orbital fracture cases, including acute, complex, and revision scenarios. My work includes published research on orbital biomechanics, surgical techniques, and multidisciplinary management strategies. This depth of exposure underpins my medicolegal opinion in cases where causation, breach of duty, prognosis, and quantum require detailed analysis.
Mechanisms
Orbital fractures typically occur via two main mechanisms:
Classification
In practice, orbital fractures are described as:
The distinction has medicolegal relevance: pure fractures often result from lower-energy but precise impacts (e.g., punches), while impure fractures are common in high-energy injuries such as road traffic collisions.
From a legal perspective, it is essential to understand how orbital injuries can affect quality of life:
In the UK, the expected standard in managing orbital fractures is informed by NICE guidelines, Royal College recommendations, and accepted maxillofacial/ophthalmic practice. Key principles include:
Failure in any of these areas may be relevant in establishing breach of duty.
Delayed or Missed Diagnosis
If swelling masks deformity, a fracture may not be diagnosed at first presentation. A medicolegal opinion will consider whether a reasonably competent clinician should have ordered imaging or referred for specialist review based on the mechanism of injury and presenting symptoms.
Suboptimal Surgery
Poorly positioned implants, inadequate release of entrapped tissue, or under-correction of orbital volume can lead to persistent symptoms. In my expert witness work, I often review postoperative imaging to assess implant position against established anatomical landmarks and pre-injury symmetry.
Failure to Refer to MDT
Complex orbital injuries benefit from input by ophthalmology, oculoplastics, and orthoptics. Failure to involve appropriate subspecialists may be criticised if it leads to avoidable harm.
Causation Analysis
Not every poor outcome results from negligence. Some injuries have an inherently poor prognosis due to the severity of initial trauma, associated globe injury, or patient-specific factors. My role is to separate these from harm caused by substandard care.
A comprehensive medicolegal assessment includes:
In litigation, prognosis influences damages. My expert reports quantify:
Costing of future treatment may include secondary orbital surgery, eyelid revision, strabismus surgery, or camouflage procedures.
I hold Bond Solon Expert Witness accreditation and have provided evidence in civil personal injury, clinical negligence, and criminal assault cases. My reports are CPR Part 35 compliant and address:
I present my opinions clearly for a non-medical audience, avoiding unnecessary jargon, but I am prepared to defend them robustly in court with reference to peer-reviewed literature and accepted practice.
One of the most compelling aspects of my work for complex or disputed cases is my access to — and leadership within — a seamless MDT comprising:
This structure mirrors the gold standard for managing orbital trauma and enables me to assess, with authority, whether a claimant’s care met that benchmark.
From a legal perspective, orbital fractures occupy a complex intersection between functional ophthalmic injury and facial disfigurement. The best outcomes rely on timely diagnosis, multidisciplinary assessment, and meticulous surgical reconstruction.
In my expert witness role, I:
With thousands of cases managed in a world-leading centre, I offer solicitors and the courts an authoritative, balanced, and clinically precise view — grounded in current best practice and extensive hands-on expertise.
Download the Information Leaflet
Medicolegal Information Sheet
All the information you neeed. Click to download to your computer or mobile device.